In our conversations and interactions with stakeholders and clients, we often find a fixation on quantitative metrics. This is a double-edged sword when it comes to public relations and communications.
Quantitative metrics provide clear-cut numbers and tangible outcomes.
So what’s the problem, they ask?
In my opinion, an over emphasis on quantitative metrics can lead to a myopic view of a brand’s performance.
The tangibility of such metrics, such as sales leads and website visits, often takes precedence, leading to a potential oversight of the nuanced, qualitative aspects that lay the foundation for these conversions.
When stakeholders become fixated solely on quantitative metrics, they risk missing out on critical insights that proxy metrics – often qualitative – can provide.
These proxy metrics, though less tangible, offer a deeper understanding of audience sentiment, engagement, and perception – all of which are fundamental to driving successful conversions.
It’s not just about getting brand new glasses, hoping to see something different with the same (data) input.
When a brand’s focus narrows to quantitative metrics, it neglects the nuances that lie beneath the surface.
Qualitative metrics can serve as vital indicators of a campaign’s efficacy.
These include a spectrum of subjective indicators, from sentiments and engagement levels to brand affinity and narrative resonance. Dismissing these qualitative aspects can hinder the brand’s ability to gauge true audience sentiment and adapt strategies accordingly.
Would you assess a painting merely by how elegant or exquisite its frame is, without diving into the intricate brushstrokes and colors that make up the masterpiece?
In PR and communications, bypassing the qualitative nuances means missing out on the relationships nurtured, the narrative crafted, and the brand sentiment cultivated – all of which are instrumental in driving eventual conversions.
Trust and reputation are not built over one campaign
Embracing both qualitative and quantitative metrics empowers communicators to paint a comprehensive picture of a brand’s performance.
Proxy metrics unearth invaluable insights into audience sentiments, preferences, and trend patterns. This deeper understanding allows for the refinement of strategies, ensuring they resonate authentically with target audiences. By blending these metrics, communications efforts can be fine-tuned to elicit more meaningful engagements and drive quantitative conversions with greater precision.
Especially for PR and communications campaigns, that often use reputation as a foundation; demonstrating proficiency in proxy metrics showcases a brand’s commitment to cultivating authentic connections.
It signals an understanding that relationships are built over time and are not mere transactional exchanges.
This nuanced approach fosters trust and credibility, two cornerstones of a resilient and enduring brand image.
Proxy metrics can go beyond traditional conversion-oriented approaches.
We share two simple use cases that underscore the nuanced power of qualitative indicators, showcasing their pivotal role in influencing brand perception, community engagement, and thought leadership recognition.
Through these applications, proxy metrics serve as precursors to conversion events and stand as credible metrics, offering a deeper understanding of audience sentiment, preferences, and advocacy potential.
This broadened perspective redefines how we assess impact, emphasising the intricate interplay between qualitative and quantitative metrics for a more comprehensive and insightful evaluation.
Communicators should feel empowered to craft strategies that resonate authentically with audiences, driving not only conversions but also long-lasting relationships and fortified reputations.
Enhance brand perception through thought leadership:
Being recognised as a thought leader in a specific industry or field holds immense value.
Qualitative proxy metrics such as the quality and relevance of content, audience engagement levels, and sentiment trends can provide crucial insights into the impact of thought leadership initiatives. This can be one-time, or over a series of audience interactions, for example at conferences, closed-door roundtables, and in industry meetings.
By analysing these factors alongside conversion metrics, brands can refine their thought leadership strategies to not only garner attention but also to influence perception and drive conversions.
Quantitative metrics such as customer attendance (and drop-out), onsite interactions and post-event appointments can be layered into the combined mix of measurements.
Community building and advocacy campaigns:
Building a loyal community around a brand is a powerful way to establish trust and drive long-term success.
Qualitative metrics such as interaction with user-generated content, testimonials as social proof, and community engagement levels serve as valuable indicators of a campaign’s efficacy.
When combined with conversion metrics – such as uptake of services, organic brand mentions of initiatives – these proxy metrics can highlight the depth of brand loyalty and the potential for advocacy-driven conversions.
Sidebar: Our brains have been hardwired to prefer numbers.
Our preference for quantitative measurements can be attributed to the psychological phenomenon known as “numerical cognition” or “numerical bias”. This cognitive tendency is rooted in our brain’s capacity for processing and categorising information efficiently. Numerical data, being precise and easily quantifiable, aligns with our brain’s natural inclination towards structure and order. This preference is supported by studies in cognitive psychology, such as those conducted by Dehaene (1997) and Gallistel and Gelman (2000), which highlight our innate numerical processing abilities.
Additionally, quantitative measurements provide a clear sense of certainty and objectivity. They offer a concrete benchmark for comparison and evaluation, reducing ambiguity and subjectivity in assessments. This aligns with the psychological concept of “cognitive ease” proposed by Kahneman (2011), which suggests that our brains tend to prefer information that is easily processed and requires less cognitive effort.
Understanding qualitative measurements requires a shift in cognitive processing. It involves engaging in more nuanced, context-dependent analysis and interpretation. To enhance our grasp of qualitative data, we can employ techniques from cognitive psychology, such as “chunking” and “pattern recognition”. Chunking involves breaking down information into meaningful chunks, which aids in processing and retaining complex qualitative data. Pattern recognition, on the other hand, allows us to identify recurring themes or trends within qualitative information.
Furthermore, adopting a mindful and empathetic approach to qualitative data analysis is crucial. This aligns with the principles of empathic listening and observational skills emphasised in psychology. Actively engaging with qualitative data allows us to tap into the emotional and subjective dimensions, providing a richer understanding of human experiences and perspectives.
Here are some ways to integrate proxy metrics into your campaigns.
Achieving a balanced approach between proxy and conversion metrics requires a thoughtful integration of both qualitative and quantitative data throughout the campaign’s lifecycle.
This strategic blend allows for a comprehensive evaluation of a brand’s impact, capturing not only the tangible outcomes but also the underlying factors that contribute to success.
When in doubt, always start (or return) to the basics.
- What are the outcomes we are trying to achieve with this campaign?
- How can I reverse engineer my measurements to provide me with clear, unambiguous data that the execution is working?
- Are the measurements and outcomes in support of my business goals/s?
At various steps of the campaign, here are some recommendations on how to integrate proxy metrics into your campaign.
Strategy:
- Conduct comprehensive audience analysis: Dive deep into audience demographics, preferences, and behaviors to inform the campaign strategy. Utilise qualitative insights to shape messaging and content that resonate authentically.
- Define clear objectives: Establish SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) goals that encompass both qualitative and quantitative metrics. This ensures a balanced approach from the outset.
Planning and operations:
- Persona-driven content mapping: Leverage qualitative insights to create detailed audience personas. Understand their pain points, preferences, and communication preferences. Use these personas to map out content strategies that resonate deeply with specific segments of the audience. By aligning content creation with qualitative audience data, brands can ensure that their messaging is not only relevant but also highly engaging.
- Media landscape analysis: Conduct a thorough qualitative analysis of the media landscape specific to the industry or niche. Identify key journalists, bloggers, and influencers who hold sway in the target market. Evaluate their content style, audience demographics, and engagement levels. This qualitative understanding enables communicators to tailor outreach efforts, ensuring they resonate with the right influencers and media outlets for maximum impact.
Campaign:
- Sentiment-driven content iteration: Monitor qualitative sentiment trends throughout the campaign. Identify shifts in audience sentiment towards specific messaging or content elements. Use this qualitative feedback to adapt and refine content mid-campaign. By leveraging sentiment-driven insights, communicators can ensure that their messaging remains in sync with audience perceptions, ultimately enhancing campaign effectiveness.
- User-generated content amplification (if applicable): Encourage and curate user-generated content (UGC) that aligns with the campaign’s objectives. Analyse the qualitative aspects of UGC, such as authenticity, resonance, and alignment with brand values. Showcase this content strategically within the campaign to foster a sense of community and trust. Qualitative indicators from UGC provide valuable social proof and enhance the campaign’s impact.
Measuring the campaign outputs:
- In-depth stakeholder interviews: Conduct in-depth qualitative interviews with key stakeholders, such as customers, partners, and industry experts. Focus on understanding their perceptions, experiences, and sentiment towards the brand. These qualitative insights provide valuable context to complement quantitative data. By incorporating stakeholder perspectives, communicators gain a more comprehensive understanding of the brand’s impact and reputation.
- Map conversion funnel with proxy metric touchpoints: Identify key touchpoints in the customer journey where proxy metrics play a critical role. Understand how qualitative indicators contribute to eventual conversions.
Reporting to stakeholders:
- Craft narrative-driven reports: Develop reports that weave together both quantitative data and qualitative insights, providing stakeholders with a holistic view of the campaign’s impact. This narrative approach helps contextualise the numbers and highlight the broader brand story.
- Visualise data for comprehensive insights: Use visual representations to juxtapose quantitative metrics with qualitative feedback, offering stakeholders a well-rounded perspective of performance. This visual storytelling enhances comprehension and emphasises the multifaceted nature of PR impact.
Join our new Run Your Own Marketing (RYOM) community at http://www.strtgcommsgrp.com/ryom.
We provide tools + resources (templates, guides, etc.), training, and solution-ing (process, curation, etc.) as well as a peer community to learn with, and to support you establishing a successful brand and business – regardless of whether you are a marketing specialist, communicator or a team member tasked to deliver the scope.
We share information like the article or post you have read, but in more detail and with more guidance on the steps.
With over 20+ years in the industry, we have created frameworks, methods and content that enable you and/or your team to deliver business outcomes relating to revenue, entry, scale, and expansion.
Here are 3 ways we support brands and communicators:
- Solutions and community: We support communicators and marketing specialists through RYOM with how-to and done-for-you tools, resources, workshops, and a hybrid system of in-person training and a cloud-based learning management system. Our proprietary content, and tools help communicators level up both skill sets and competencies, while solving current communications and marketing challenges.
- Business matching: We act as a middleman to match brands, agencies and contractors based on specific PR and marketing needs and outcomes.
- Consultancy and enablement: My team supports brands and agencies with a plug-and-play strategy and execution solution.
Set up a meeting with us if you are looking for to deliver growth outcomes for your organisation, brand or team.
And subscribe to join over 1500+ communicators and brands getting value every Tuesday while reading A Communicator’s Perspective, our weekly newsletter.